Anarchist Cookbook ‘Bible’ Raises Eyebrows

A triangular warning sign with an exclamation mark against a blue sky
Photo: nito / Shutterstock

A Phoenix-area man now sits in jail accused of planning to bomb two houses of worship and shoot down anyone who ran for safety.

Quick Take

  • Matthew Bjornholt faces a terroristic threat charge in Maricopa County, Arizona.
  • Prosecutors say he planned to bomb a Jewish or Muslim site, then let an accomplice shoot survivors.s
  • A home search turned up three guns and a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, which he called his “Bible”
  • The FBI reviewed his phones and declined to bring federal charges
  • His attorney calls the case fabricated hearsay from a former friend Bjornholt had just kicked out

What Prosecutors Say Happened

Court records describe a chilling plan. Bjornholt allegedly said he would set off a bomb at one place of worship as a distraction, then detonate a bigger bomb at a nearby site. An accomplice would wait outside and start “picking off people” who tried to flee, prosecutors said. The alleged targets were Jewish or Muslim institutions, though the exact Maricopa County locations have not been made public.

The claim did not come from wiretaps or undercover agents. It came from a witness who reported the alleged conversations to authorities. That single-source origin matters because it means the case currently rests heavily on one person’s word against the defendant’s, with no public recordings or confirmed written messages yet.

The Search That Followed

Investigators searched Bjornholt’s home and found three firearms along with a copy of The Anarchist Cookbook, a text containing explosive-making instructions. Prosecutors told the court he referred to the book as his “Bib.” Notably, no bomb-making materials, chemicals, or components were reportedly found anywhere in the home, a gap that weakens the picture of a plot already in motion.

A Judge Lets the Case Move Forward

A judge found enough evidence to establish probable cause, allowing the state’s case to continue. The court set a $100,000 secured bond and ordered strict conditions: electronic monitoring, no weapons, and no contact with witnesses or alleged victims. Probable cause is a low legal bar. It means a judge saw enough to proceed to trial, not that guilt has been proven or that the plan was operational.

The only charge filed so far is one count of making a terroristic threat. That is a far narrower charge than conspiracy to commit mass murder or possession of weapons of mass destruction, and it reflects how much remains unproven about whether any concrete steps toward an attack ever took place.

The Defense Pushes Back Hard

Defense attorney Chad Shell did not hedge. He said Bjornholt never made the alleged statements to anyone and called the entire account fabricated. He described the accuser as a former friend Bjornholt had thrown out of his house just two days before the alleged statements were supposedly made, framing the claim as a grudge rather than a confession.

Shell also said Bjornholt voluntarily unlocked his phones and devices for federal investigators. According to the defense, agents searched everything and found nothing tied to terrorism. He noted the three firearms were legally owned, with no more than twenty rounds of ammunition per weapon, which is a standard magazine load, not a stockpile.

Why Federal and State Authorities Split

The FBI reviewed the case and chose not to file federal charges. Maricopa County prosecutors moved forward anyway with the state terroristic threat count. No public explanation has been given for why federal investigators passed, leaving an open question about whether they saw the evidence as too thin or simply outside their jurisdiction.

That disagreement between federal and state authorities is not unusual, but it deserves scrutiny. When the agency with the most resources and the deepest terrorism expertise declines to charge someone, the public is owed clarity on why, especially when a case this serious is still moving forward at the local level.

A Pattern Bigger Than One Case

Since the September 11 terrorist attacks, federal prosecutors have leaned harder into stopping attacks before they happen rather than punishing completed ones. One study of federal terrorism indictments found the share aimed at prevention jumped from 29 percent before 9/11 to 60 percent after it. Houses of worship remain rare but real targets, with 59 documented violent attacks nationwide between 2012 and 2022.

That shift toward prevention is good policy; catching real threats early saves lives. But it also raises the stakes for getting it right. Advocacy group CAIR-Arizona welcomed the state charges and pushed for federal action too, showing how quickly an accusation can become a cause before a jury ever hears the evidence.

Sources:

nypost.com, azfamily.com, azcentral.com, tucson.com, newsweek.com, whmi.com, yahoo.com