
An Alabama judge is telling the public that a law built to keep violent suspects behind bars before trial attacks a right every American is supposed to have: the presumption of innocence.
Quick Take
- Circuit Court Judge David Carpenter called Aniah’s Law a “direct assault” on the presumption of innocence in a public social media statement.
- The law lets Alabama judges deny bond to people charged with certain violent crimes, including murder and kidnapping.
- Carpenter has denied bond under the same law himself, including in a 2025 case involving a Hoover shooting death.
- Supporters, including state senators and Alabama mayors, call the law a needed tool to stop dangerous defendants from hurting more people.
What The Judge Actually Said
Carpenter wrote that laws letting the government hold people in jail “based on a charge only” are “a direct assault on the Constitutional guarantee of the presumption of innocence.” He said, comparing Aniah’s Law to the public fight over license-plate cameras, that expanded detention power deserves just as much scrutiny.
1819 News, which first reported the quote, labeled Carpenter a “self-proclaimed Democratic Socialist” judge and tied his comment to earlier controversy over his bond decisions in cases involving Damien McDaniel and Raukeem Cunningham. That framing turns a legal argument into a political fight over Carpenter’s record.
Where Aniah’s Law Came From
Alabama voters approved Aniah’s Law in 2022 after the murder of Aniah Blanchard. Her accused killer, Ibraheem Yazeed, was reportedly out on bond for other charges when she died. The law let judges deny bond to people charged with the most serious violent crimes.
Lawmakers later pushed to expand it further. The added offenses include attempted murder, conspiracy to commit murder, and shooting into an occupied home, building, or vehicle. That expansion widened the list of charges that can keep a defendant locked up without bond.
Carpenter’s Own Rulings Complicate His Argument
Carpenter’s criticism runs into a problem: his own courtroom record. In March 2025, he denied bond to Jonathan Barclay in a Hoover shooting death case after an Aniah’s Law hearing. Carpenter cited multiple witnesses, possible incriminating statements, and the violent nature of the crime.
That ruling shows Carpenter applying the law with real evidence and individual findings, not detention based on a charge alone. Critics say this gap between his public rhetoric and his courtroom conduct makes his constitutional alarm sound inconsistent, maybe even self-serving given past criticism of his bond decisions.
Why Supporters See It Differently
State senators and city leaders argue the law does the opposite of what Carpenter describes. Senator Rodger Smitherman said judges should be able to detain people they determine are dangers to society, while Senator Andrew Jones said strengthening the law keeps dangerous people “locked up” instead of back on the streets before trial.
Alabama’s Big 10 mayors went further, writing that the law gives judges “the tools they need” to protect innocent families and stop repeat violent offenders from striking again. They frame it as a victim-protection measure, not a constitutional shortcut around due process.
Even some officials pushing changes acknowledge due-process concerns deserve attention. A chief of staff for Alabama’s Chief Justice backed giving defense attorneys more time before detention hearings, so evidence gets reviewed properly instead of rushed. That is a reasonable middle ground worth taking seriously.
Democratic judge under fire for releasing violent offenders calls bail law a 'direct assault' on rights https://t.co/6VbEJtBmMD pic.twitter.com/NBitQGH2hh
— New York Post (@nypost) November 17, 2026
What The Law Actually Requires
The U.S. Supreme Court already weighed in on this exact tension decades ago. In United States v. Salerno, the Court upheld federal pretrial detention law, ruling that holding dangerous defendants before trial serves a legitimate public safety purpose and does not automatically violate due process when real procedural protections exist.
That precedent matters here. Aniah’s Law requires a hearing, not just a charge, before a judge can deny bond. Carpenter’s own Barclay ruling shows judges are weighing actual evidence, which aligns with what the Supreme Court has already found constitutionally acceptable.
The Bottom Line For Alabama Families
Common sense and public safety both favor giving judges real tools to keep violent, dangerous defendants off the streets while cases move through the courts. Aniah’s Law exists because a young woman was killed by a man free on bond. That fact should weigh heavily against abstract constitutional alarm bells not backed by a single successful legal challenge.
Sources:
foxnews.com, 1819news.com, x.com, newsagentdata.com, al.com, yellowhammernews.com, wbrc.com












